J.FitzPatrick Footwear

Puyallup - Gold Museum Calf / Forest Tweed

$395 $495

Style is all about reinvention and the button boot is the perfect example of that notion. Being popularized in the late 1800’s and being worn throughout the Edwardian/Victorian eras, you once found that it was the common form of footwear for those of style, and of course, means.

The Puyallup is a newer addition to our button boot collection due to the brogueing and cap toe. This new colorway in Gold Museum / Forest Tweed is the perfect color palette for the upcoming season. Pair with fawn to navy trousers and a nice tweed sports jacket to complete the look.

Please note that button hooks are sold separately.

When adding a custom patina to your order, please specify in your cart checkout notes what color and style of patina you would like--whether it's something we've done before, or something totally new! For patina prices and existing color references, please visit our patina service information page.


    Please note that leather is an organic material which will experience natural variations in color. We strive for consistency during production, and do our best to accurately represent each style’s color under natural light, but minor variations may nevertheless occur. If you would like to preview photos of the specific pair you would be receiving, please let us know via email at: nyc@jfitzpatrickfootwear.com

    • Last NGT
    • Ilcea Museum Calf (Italy) / Forest Tweed 
    • Buttons by Richard James Weldon
    • Leatherboard Heel Stiffeners
    • Hand-Lasted Waists
    • Indented 5 Brass Nails
    • Leather/Metal combination shank (no plastic)
    • Single Leather Flex Sole
    • Goodyear Welted
    • Fully Leather Lined
    • Made in Spain
    • This color will need to be stripped to add a custom patina

    The NGT is our smart-round last. Its slender silhouette and elongated toe box result in a classic, elegant style.

    The NGT is one our more refined fitting lasts, and is therefore more suited for narrow to medium width feet:

    • Narrower/shallower forefoot
    • Less voluminous (but not “low”) instep
    • Hugging arch area
    • Elongated shape
    • Not good for wide feet
    • Fits more generously on boots than on shoes

    J.FitzPatrick shoes have a broad set of fit options, from true to size, on the slim side to more wide. It will be important to make sure you read about the specific last that you are looking to purchase.

    One thing to note across the board is that our loafers have been cut on the snug side, compared to the rest of the models. We did this so that you do not need to 'size down' when going for a loafer, rather recommending you stick to your oxford size (**read exception below)

    Here are a few general rules

    • Our insteps would be considered generous
    • All shoes with 6 eyelets will be even more generous in the instep
    • Any model in full suede will feel more generous to its leather counterpart
    • The boots have a forgiving instep in order for you to put them on easily
    • Any monkstrap made on the MGF or LPB will feel more generous to its oxford counterpart
    • If you wear your oxfords very snug, then size up for your loafers. However, for most we recommend taking the same size as your oxfords
    7 6 40 25
    7.5 6.5 40.5 25.5
    8 7 41 26
    8.5 7.5 41.5 26.5
    9 8 42 27
    9.5 8.5 42.5 27.5
    10 9 43 28
    10.5 9.5 43.5 28.5
    11 10 44 29
    11.5 10.5 44.5 29.5
    12 11 45 30
    12.5 11.5 45.5 30.5
    13 12 46 31

    All orders above $375 shipped within the United States include free shipping via UPS ground shipping. Should you require a faster shipment via USPS or UPS, additional fees will apply.

    The USPS 2-day priority mail service used within the US aims to arrive within 2-3 working days depending on location. This is not a guarantee, however. Your tracking number provided will keep you up to date with your parcel. 

    We look to ship out all purchases 1-2 working days after the time of purchase (weekends not included). During "Sale" periods we aim to ship between 2 -4 days after the time of purchase as the increase in orders affects our ability to be any quicker. Add-ons involving changes to your shoes (toe taps, rubber sole bottoms) will increase delivery time by 7-14 days. Custom patinas will increase delivery time by 14 days.


    All International Orders are shipped from NYC using DHL, UPS or USPS. We will use the service that offers us the best rate. If you prefer one over the other and the one that you prefer is significantly more expensive then we will ask that you pay the difference between the best rate and the rate your preferred courier offers.

    If you prefer another courier, such as UPS, USPS or FedEx and wish to pay the difference (if the one you want is more than the rate we pay to DHL), please indicate this in the notes section of your order. Any failure to do so, will result us using the DHL service. Before sending your parcel, we will send an invoice to cover the difference in pricing (should there by any).

    Any and all import duties imposed by your local custom's officials on your parcel will be the responsibility of the customer to pay for. We do not control this and will not be held responsible for any surprises in charges as we do not impose them. Your government does. We declare the parcel at the value paid. We do no under-declare parcel values. Please do not ask us to do so.

    Please note, if you reject your order for not wanting to pay the custom's import taxation, we will be charged a fee for the return shipping. This fee will come out of your refund as we will are not liable for this charge due to your error in ordering. 

    For Remote Labeled Areas a surcharge of the price difference between what we normally pay and what they are quoting will be required to make shipment.

    We look to ship out all purchases 1-2 working days after the time of purchase (weekends not included). During "Sale" periods we aim to ship between 2 -4 days after the time of purchase as the increase in orders affects our ability to be any quicker.

    For a general guide on shipping cost, please refer to our shipping chart below.

    We ensure each purchase during the time it is in transit until it is delivered to you. We require a signature for any goods delivered, at which point responsibility for your purchased goods passes on to the customer. If you are not the receiver of your purchase (for example a gift order) then the person who signs for the package confirms receipt and is accountable for the package.

    Orders shipped with different billing/shipping addresses will be scrutinized by our Anti-Fraud system. Of course we understand if one wants to ship to their work address. And we reserve the right to cancel any order that has been deemed fraudulent by our system.

    Destination $0   - $199.99 $200   - $399.99 +$400
    USA   (ex. AK, HI, PR) $20 $10 Free
    Alaska/Hawaii/Puerto   Rico $30 $15 Free
    Asia / Africa $60 $50 $40
    Australia/New Zealand $60 $50 $40
    Canada $30 $20 $10
    Central America/Caribbean $50 $35 $20
    Mexico $30 $20 $10
    South America $60 $40 $30
    EU $60 $45 $30

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 2 reviews
    Andrew Allred
    Elegant, beautiful, and conservatively eccentric

    This is a beautiful shoe aesthetically. The tweed paired with the leather is an excellent, noticeable but reserved pattern. The buttons add a sense of uniqueness that is rooted in Victorian charm. The stitching of the sole to the welt is very well done for this price range - superior and more tightly stitched than Allen Edmonds. No visible flaws in the construction. I love my Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue dress boots in dark brown (now discontinued I believe), but this is now my most spectacular pair of shoes.

    Literally the first day I wore these shoes out (I was nervous - these shoes are somewhat "loud" for where I live in a mid-sized city in the Southeast), I got two great compliments from total strangers - one man, one woman.

    By way of comparison, I own 2 Allen Edmonds on the 65 last, 1 Allen Edmonds Randolph loafers (not sure which last), 1 Meermin loafers, 1 Churches oxfords (only bench grade, which seems to be fake leather), and a few other pairs of mediocre-good quality welted loafers. On an Allen Edmonds 65 last (Park Avenue, McAllister, Fifth Ave dress boot), I wear a 11.5D (although if there were something between a C and D, that would be me - I should probably push to 12 in C because the 65 last pinches my pinky toes in 11.5C in the McAllister). I purchased an 11.5 here on the NGT last. Wonderful fit. More snug than the Allen Edmonds D, but only just so. Perfect for me.

    When I called for sizing, the first words I heard were "Hello this is Justin". Really, really cool to have spoken with the founder of this Company (and received patient, perfect fitting advice) before purchasing his shoes. That was a nice, "small town" touch that will make me remember my purchase. Very well done Justin. I am checking out only with a pair of your brown Magnolia oxfords right now.

    If you are like me, you have now looked at these shoes 37 times and are still on the fence - "are they too much?" "$495 is a lot...". Just buy them. You won't regret it.


    PS: Wear with olive green wool slacks and a blue button down to work for the perfect look.

    Alex Ogle
    I get compliments about these most times I wear them

    I have a earlier version of these that I bought from Mr Fitzpatrick when he was still in London. Fortunately, the strength and skill needed in your fingers to button these up is developed quickly and a well worn pair can tear open to take off easily. The leather looks better on these newer ones, but mine come up to a heady polish and are spectacular with the right trousers.

    Related Products

    Recently viewed